
February
2001
|

Central
and Eastern European Countries
Synthesis 1999 - 2000 |
This is the final WWW Indicators
report on CEEC as the ESIS project ended in January 2001. It covers the whole
period of the ESIS project surveying the Central and Eastern European Countries.
Introduction
The following report provides an
estimation of the number of Web sites developed by relevant
categories of actors in the Central and Eastern European Countries. The 7 categories under study are : Primary and secondary schools; higher
educational schools and universities; National ministries; Regional and local
authorities (regions, departments/counties, municipalities); Hospitals/clinics;
museums; Libraries (word of caution).
Different levels of equipment exist depending on categories and
depending on the countries. Therefore this synthesis is composed of four parts:
-
Part 1 : classification based on the
level of web sites penetration by category ranging from Low to High.
-
Part 2 : synthesis per country relating
main tendencies and a short explanation.
-
Part 3 : percentage of websites per
sector in the CEEC Countries
-
Part 4 : Comparison
of the quarterly evolution of web sites in different categories
What is interesting to note is that most of the countries
experienced a slight but constant growth in the majority of categories. Some of
them, then, have shown sustained growth rates. Then we’ll see more in depth
that two or three recurrent categories are usually considered as priorities, top
priorities categories, as for Mediterranean countries, being High Schools &
Universities and Ministries.
At last what is important to take in account is that this web
sites level of equipment analysis gives a picture of the equipment in public
institutions only, privates sectors being not considered. Evaluation of the
level of equipment of a country has therefore to be considered cautiously.
1. Web Sites
spreads and categories
This part consists of an overview of Web Sites evolution
through the past 7 quarter, from July 1999 to January 2001.
First, we can notice that the level of Web Sites
penetration is heterogeneous depending on the category. We distinguish low,
intermediate and highly equipped categories.
|
Low level of equipment
|
-
Primary and Secondary schools
-
Libraries
|
|
Intermediate level of equipment
|
-
Regional & Local Authorities
-
Museums
-
Hospitals / clinics
|
|
High level of equipment
|
- High schools and universities
-
Ministries
|
Here below is an insight of countries being part of these
three categories :
1.1 Low level of equipment:
- Primary & Secondary schools :
Slovenia was the most largely equipped by mid 2000 even though data for the
two following periods are missing. Estonia and Czech Republic have also
experienced constant and sustained growth over the seven quarter of
observation, respectively with 37.8 and 27% of web sites rates in the category.
All others countries have shown rates of equipment lower than 20%.
- Libraries:
Slovenia has yet shown the highest growth rate in
this category with rising from 41.5% in Q3 up to 86% by Q5. The Slovenian rate
has been steady since the first quarter of observation with a 50% rate of
equipment. At last, Slovakia for its first period of observation in Q7 has
appeared to be ranked second considering the level of equipment. All others
countries except Lithuania (slightly over 10% ) have a level of equipment
lower than 10%.
1.2 Intermediate level of equipment:
- Regional & Local Authorities: We can distinguish two
kind of evolutions. The first kind gathers countries having evolved through
the observed period below a 20% rate of equipment. All of them have shown a
quasi steady evolution. The second kind are countries having experienced
strong growth through the period with current rates above 50%. Three
countries by order of ranking Bosnia (84.6%), Estonia (66.7%) then Poland
(50.6%), are in this case. All others countries are in the other one. At
last Slovenia was at an intermediate level by mid 2000 its last available
rate being equal to 47%.
- Museums:
This category is also at an intermediate level with
countries ranging from insufficiently equipped to above 50% rates. Countries
the most in advance in terms of web sites penetration in this category are
Latvia (77.4%), Bosnia (60%) and Lithuania (93.6%). Note that unlike Latvia,
which has decreased over the first two quarter from a 100% down to a steady
77.4% within the five next, Bosnia and Lithuania have shown the highest
growths. Others countries range below 40%, Romania, Macedonia and Bulgaria
being the least equipped ones.
- Hospitals/Clinics:
This category counts six fairly equipped
countries, of which Czech Republic and Hungary are the top countries with the
highest growth rates. We can note the outstanding growth of Czech Republic
which has increased its rate of penetration by 200% over the period of
observation. Bosnia, Estonia and Bulgaria have also known significant growth
rates, their current rates being comprised between 30 and 40%. All others
countries have evolved below 20%.
1.3 High level of equipment:
- High Schools & Universities:. What is interesting to
note when considering this category is that it appears to be part of the 2 top
priorities concerning web sites equipment. Thus 4 countries, Bosnia,
Hungary, Lithuania and Slovakia are fully equipped with a 100% rate. 3
others countries, Bulgaria, Latvia, Poland and Czech Republic have reached
current rates higher than 80%. We can notice that Latvia, Czech Republic and
Estonia have experienced the highest growth rate through the period of
observation, Estonia reaching 75% in this last quarter. Only FYR Macedonia,
Romania and especially Albania are delayed with respective current rates
equals to 28, 18 and 1% and a non evolution at all for 2 of them.
- Ministries: This category, as for the Mediterranean countries
is the most updated one in terms of web sites equipment. Four
countries, Estonia, Hungary, Lithuania, and Slovenia were already fully
equipped at the beginning of the period and are still. Two countries,
Latvia and Poland have reached a full penetration rate through the period.
Slovakia which is present for the first time this quarter is also fully
equipped. Others less equipped countries are FYR Macedonia, Albania and
Romania with respective rates comprised between 60 and 70%. Note that
Romania has decreased from 98 to 25% over the three first quarters before
rising up continuously then. No country is currently under 59%.
2. Web
characteristics by country
: There are over 1500 primary schools and 1700 secondary schools in
Albania and none of them have a web site. A LAN project is to be
undertaken closed to universities by the Ministry of Education and
Science. Changes related to Universities and Libraries are explained by
the same Ministry contribution and also to the SOROS foundation. The same
foundation is the only one to provide with a free internet service to
institutions. Indeed, Internet services remain expensive due to the low
level of use (4600 users in Albania). Albania appears to be one of the
least equipped country in Central Europe.
Bosnia & Herzegovina
: Universities and Authorities are very well served. A rise is to be due in
the others categories. Internet development is perceived as an opportunity for
the economic expansion. Nevertheless the country is in a post war phase and
many others points have also to be considered among others telecom
infrastructure reconstruction. At last the Internet use is very limited and
costs of use remain very high. Bosnia is basically located at an upper
intermediate level compared to others Central European countries.
Czech Republic :
This
country has experienced one of the highest if not the highest growth in
terms of public web sites penetration. Czech Republic is at an intermediate
level with its highest rates in High Schools & Universities, National
Ministries and Hospitals/Clinics. Public administration institutions lack
funds and therefore can’t have their own web sites, even though
compromises have been done by hosting several institutions on a central
site. It thus enables 100% of institutions to be represented among Regional
& Local Authorities, Museums and Libraries categories.
Bulgaria
: no data available
Estonia :
Estonia
has experienced constant increases in all categories except in Museums and in
Libraries categories. Among highest growth rates are Primary & Secondary
schools and Regional & Local Authorities. It is interesting to note that
Estonia is the second most largely equipped CEEC country concerning the
Primary & Secondary Schools category. Note also that the dramatic rise in
the Regional & Local Authorities category is partially due to the absence
of registering in directories and search engines before April 2000. National
Ministries category is fully equipped and Universities category is the second
best served category. To conclude what we notice is that Estonia is globally
one of the Central European countries having experienced the highest growth
rates through the period of observation. It is located at an upper
intermediate level in terms of web sites penetration considering others
Central European countries. Development of Internet web sites intended to
non profit organisations is largely supported by "The Open Estonia
Foundation".
Hungary :
High
Schools & Universities and National Ministries categories are the most
served categories with both of these ones fully equipped, since the beginning
of ESIS II period for National Ministries. All Hungarian secondary
schools have Internet Access thanks to the Sulinet Program, but all of them
haven’t their own web site. Others categories don’t show a large web site
penetration. The high difference between the two last quarters in
Hospital/Clinics category is due to the change of statistical measures to
evaluate their numbers. Hungary is located at a low level of equipment
compared to others Central European countries.
Latvia :
High
School & Universities and National Ministries categories are as always the
most largely served categories. Note that all High Schools and Universities
have gathered now enough financial resources and that the National
Ministries category is fully equipped since quarter 6. Web Sites penetration
is far less important in Primary & Secondary even if a new program was
launched by the government to computerise schools. Museums were fully
equipped at the beginning of the period thanks to an Australian specialist
who put all of them on the Web. Then through quarter 3 the museum definition
changed, what brought to the decrease due to the consideration of local
museums (unequipped) as museums. All others categories have low levels of
equipment. Latvia remains at a low level of equipment among others Central
European countries.
Lithuania :
National
Ministries and High Schools and Universities were fully equipped from the
first quarter of observation. Web Sites increase in public institutions was
low but Sites are better structured. Constant increases in Primary &
Secondary schools category, then in Museums and Libraries were for a large
part of them financed by the Lithuanian Soros Foundation (OSF), private
funds and private companies. Thus a significant effort is made to promote
Lithuanian art and culture as its outstanding growth and equipment rates
show it. Lithuania is at an intermediate level in terms of Web Sites
penetration compared to others Central European Countries.
FYR Macedonia :
Macedonia
is one of the or the lowest equipped Central European country in terms of
Web Sites penetration. Indeed, all categories show penetration rates amongst
the lowest of the Central European countries. National Ministries, with a
December 00 penetration rate of 71% is the most largely equipped category :
its penetration rate has remained steady over the period, the slight
increase between quarter 4 and 5 being due to the reduction in the number of
ministries. Then except Universities and Hospitals/Clinics categories, all
others categories have rates located below 10%. At last the equipment increase
from 0 to 4% for Primary and Secondary Schools is explained by the OSIM’s
(Open Society Institute – Macedonia) sponsorship.
Poland :
Universities
and National Ministries categories are the most largely equipped with currently
respectively 90 and 100% penetration rates, National Ministries being fully
equipped for 4 quarters now. Regional & Local Authorities has
experienced a strong growth over the period rising from 15 up to a current
51%. Others categories are located under 20%, even though all of them have had
sustained constant growth. Poland in the overall is at an intermediate level
compared to others Central European countries.
Romania :
Romania
takes part of countries with the lower penetration. National Ministries with
a 62% equipment rate is the most largely equipped category. High schools &
Universities category has experienced a constant growth over the period of
observation and is still expected to increase its number of Web Sites,
mainly thanks to the connection of thus category to the RoEduNet network
(Romanian Education Network). This network is intended to connect non profit
institutions to the Internet. All other categories remain under 10% due mainly
to the high and very scattered number of institutions and difficulties to
find necessary funds. Regional & Local Authorities are expected to
develop more in the short term.
Slovakia :
Slovakia
started to participate while this quarter to the ESIS observation project.
Data related to the current quarter are therefore only available. High
Schools & Universities and National Ministries are fully equipped.
Libraries category shows a significant penetration rates but are exclusive of
municipal and schools ones. Museums has a 33% penetration rate. Primary
& Secondary Schools are under equipped with a penetration rate closed to
0. Slovakia in the overall is located at a low intermediate level of
equipment.
Slovenia :
Slovenia
has seen the highest growth in the Primary & Secondary schools category and in the Libraries one. Penetration rates for both of these
categories are
also at the ranked first with rates next to 90%. It is also part of the most
equipped countries concerning the majority of categories. Indeed Slovenia is
fully equipped in the Ministries category and is part of the top 3 in Regional
& Local Authorities (70%), High Schools and Universities (88.9%) and
Hospitals/Clinics (53.9%) categories. To sum up, Slovenia is if not the most,
one of the most largely equipped country compared to others CEEC countries.
3.
Percentage of websites per sector in the CEEC Countries
|
|
Primary and
secondary schools |
High schools
and universities |
National
ministries |
Regional and
local authorities |
Hospitals
clinics |
Museums |
Libraries |
|
Albania |
0,03 |
1 |
59 |
3 |
0 |
0 |
4 |
|
Bosnia |
11,7 |
100 |
|
84,6 |
40 |
60 |
50 |
|
Bulgaria |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Estonia |
37,8 |
75,8 |
100 |
66,8 |
28,2 |
26,8 |
4,3 |
|
FYR
Macedonia |
4 |
28 |
71 |
4 |
18 |
7 |
|
|
Hungary |
28 |
30 |
100 |
21,42 |
52,87 |
19,91 |
9,5 |
|
Latvia |
14,1 |
84,8 |
100 |
14,3 |
8 |
77,4 |
2,4 |
|
Lithuania |
11,6 |
100 |
100 |
16,5 |
22,1 |
93,75 |
17,2 |
|
Poland |
14,5 |
90,6 |
100 |
51 |
19 |
17,7 |
6,3 |
|
Romania |
0,5 |
17,8 |
62,5 |
9,2 |
1,9 |
1,8 |
0,1 |
|
Slovakia |
1,67 |
100 |
100 |
9 |
11 |
33,7 |
75 |
|
Slovenia |
84 |
89 |
100 |
70 |
54 |
45,9 |
96,9 |
|
Czech Republic |
27 |
86,9 |
100 |
12,9 |
62,2 |
52,1 |
7 |
|
|
Primary and
secondary schools |
High schools
and universities |
National
ministries |
Regional and
local authorities |
Hospitals /
clinics |
Museums |
Libraries |
|
Albania |
0,03%
(1of 3200) |
1%
(7 of 506) |
59%
(13 of 22) |
3%
(15 of 474) |
0%
(0 of 2488) |
0%
(0 of 28) |
4%
(3 of 70) |
|
Bosnia |
11,7%
(30 of 256) |
100%
(64 of 64) |
. |
84,6%
(55 of 65) |
40%
(40 of 100) |
60%
(6 of 10) |
50%
(5 of 10) |
|
Bulgaria |
.
|
.
|
.
|
.
|
.
|
.
|
.
|
|
Estonia |
37,8%
(267 of 706) |
75,8%
(25 of 33) |
100%
(12 of 12) |
66,8%
(175 of 262) |
28,2%
(22 of 78) |
26,8%
(48 of 179) |
4,3%
(30 of 691) |
|
FYR
Macedonia |
4%
(42 of 1048) |
28%
(2 of 7) |
71%
(10 of 14) |
4%
(4 of 124) |
18%
(7 of 39) |
7%
(4 of 58) |
. |
|
Hungary |
28%
(1710 of 9219) |
100%
(30 of 30) |
100%
(14 of 14) |
21,42%
(681 of 3178) |
52,87%
(92 of 174) |
19,91%
(180 of 904) |
9,5%
(332 of 3379) |
|
Latvia |
14,1%
(151 of 1074) |
84,8%
(28 of 33) |
100%
(12 of 12) |
14,3%
(76 of 532) |
8%
(12 of 150) |
77,4%
(96 of 124) |
2,4%
(24 of 980) |
|
Lithuania |
11,6%
(151 of 1301) |
100%
(16 of 16) |
100%
(13 of 13) |
16,5%
(85 of 515) |
22,1%
(42 of 190) |
93,75%
(75 of 80) |
17,2%
(55 of 320) |
|
Poland |
14,5%
(4950 of 34086) |
90,6%
(260 of 287) |
100%
(16 of 16) |
51%
(1478 of 2896) |
19%
(135 of 711) |
17,7%
(110 of 623) |
6,3%
(500 of 8000) |
|
Romania |
0,5%
(70 of 13847) |
17,8%
(324 of 1825) |
62,5%
(10 of 16) |
9,2%
(274 of 2989) |
1,9%
(17 of 887) |
1,8%
(9 of 512) |
0,1%
(14 of 13848) |
|
Slovakia |
1,67%
(63 of 3770) |
100%
(23 of 23) |
100%
(16 of 16) |
9%
(8 of 87) |
11%
(31 of 92) |
33,7%
(31 of 92) |
75%
(36 of 48) |
|
Slovenia |
84,1%
(410 of 606) |
88,9%
(16 of 18) |
100%
(16 of 16) |
70,1%
(174 of 248) |
53,9%
(14 of 26) |
45,9%
(39 of 85) |
96,9%
(63 of 65) |
|
Czech Republic |
27%
(1433 of 5308) |
86,9%
(172 of 198) |
100%
(14 of 14) |
12,9%
(6440 of 6440) |
62,2%
(199 of 320) |
52,1%
(441 of 441) |
7%
(442 of 6286) |
4.
Comparison of the quarterly evolution of web sites in different categories from Q1
(July 1999) to Q7 (January 2001)







Word
of caution
-
The
notion High Schools
does not correspond to the US
notion. High Schools are all
superior schools belonging to
the category of Higher
Education, as there are e.g.
Technical Universities,
Business Schools or other
education establishments
corresponding to universities
with students over ~ 20 years
of age.
-
Regional
and local authorities:
where local authorities do not
exist as elected
"decentralised
bodies", we include
administrative units in charge
of local and regional affairs,
even if they are linked to the
organisation of the state. For
example, mayors, even if not
directly elected, are
included.
-
Hospitals
and clinics: this
category comprises larger
hospitals and clinics, be they
public or private. Smaller
health units are counted, as
they are unlikely to have
websites and their inclusion
would distort the overall
picture.
Important :
the data must be considered
with care and only as estimates and general indications.
In fact, there are no central bodies allowing a
"scientific" monitoring and the comparison
between the countries is difficult due to this situation
and also to the disparities of the national
organisational systems (for example, number of cities).
|
